坦克世界吧 关注:3,866,402贴子:116,936,154

【转载】转自ST 流言碾压者

只看楼主收藏回复

题记:辟谣是违法的
by——某国司法解释
Common Myths About WWII
【流言碾压者】二战常见流言
Posted on September 5, 2013 by EnsignExpendable - 59 Comments ↓
Before you guys start whining about Communist propaganda, SS asked me to do this, and The_Chieftain (WGA’s historian) put in his corrections into the list, as well as various posters of the World of Tanks NA forums. Some of these should be familiar to you, while others are a little more obscure. Still, don’t repeat them!
诸君且稍安勿躁,本文是SS让本穷贴的,还有The_Chieftain(白毛子的美服战史专家)还和美服论坛的玩家一起替我校书。有一些流言应该是各位熟知的,只有一小部门比较冷门。嘛,你们看看就行了别乱传啊~


IP属地:广东1楼2013-09-09 10:03回复
    Myth: The Germans enjoyed unprecedented success in Europe due to the “Blitzkrieg” doctrine.
    流言:德军依靠“闪击战”学说在欧洲取得了无与伦比的胜利
    Fact: Blitzkrieg was never a doctrine. Zinegata explored the topic here.
    真相:闪击战从来就不是一种学说。Zinegata解释过了。
    http://forum.worldoftanks.com/in ... blitzkrieg-decoded/


    IP属地:广东5楼2013-09-09 10:05
    收起回复
      2025-08-06 06:55:02
      广告
      不感兴趣
      开通SVIP免广告
      Myth: German and crews were superior to anything the Allies had, and achieved an X:1 kill to death ratio (the number varies greatly).
      流言:德军乘员素质优秀,远超一切盟军,随便都能打出N:1的交换比来(N有N个版本)
      Fact: The flaws of German kill counts are covered in detail here and here.
      真相: 德国人的歼敌记录水分之大呵呵呵。。。。
      http://ftr.wot-news.com/2013/08/03/cheating-at-statistics/
      http://ftr.wot-news.com/2013/07/28/please-dont-use-the-5-m4s-1-panther-myth/


      IP属地:广东6楼2013-09-09 10:05
      回复
        Myth: Soviet optics were abysmal, and their guns inaccurate, to the point where they could not engage enemy targets at more than a few hundred meters.
        流言:苏联的观瞄设备恶劣,火炮也打不准,因此仅能在二、三百米的近距离上接敌。
        Fact: Soviet guns do not lack mechanical accuracy, and are occasionally more accurate than their German counterparts. As for optics, Americans praised them at Aberdeen trials: “Consensus: the gun sights are the best in the world. Incomparable to any currently known worldwide or currently developed in America.”.
        真相:苏联火炮精度不差,甚至不输德制。例如观瞄设备,美国人就曾在阿伯丁试验场的测试中大加褒扬:“一致同意:此炮瞄镜天下无双。世上已有或美国正在研发中的产品均无可与之匹敌者。”【译者注:本穷参观过北京昌平的坦博,在进口的老式IS里面把玩过其炮瞄镜和潜望镜,虽然已经生产了60年之久,但仍然色泽清晰,无气泡,无龟裂,边缘无紫色偏光。当然,本穷分不出好和特别好的区别,但至少觉得用这样质量的瞄准镜看着还是很舒服清晰的】


        IP属地:广东7楼2013-09-09 10:06
        收起回复
          Myth: Germans had the best optics in the entire war.
          流言:德国人的光学设备是整个战争中最好的。
          Fact: Not really, just some minor advantages in sight form factors (and not glass quality, like is often said). Daigensui explores the topic here. (Credit: Daigensui)
          真相:不实,仅在视觉形式的因素(而不是常说的玻璃质量)上有一些小优势罢了。可参考Daigensui的说明
          http://forum.worldoftanks.com/index.php?/topic/265163-german-optics/


          IP属地:广东12楼2013-09-09 10:09
          收起回复


            IP属地:山东来自Android客户端15楼2013-09-09 10:10
            回复
              Myth: The Panther was a great tank that could have turned the tide of the war if only _________.
              流言:豹子精良无比,要是XXXX的话,说不定能改变战争态势。
              Fact: Panthers, even the latest models, were full of mechanical issues, such as final drives that lasted 150 kilometers. The_Chieftain goes over them here. Additionally, the armour was of exceptionally poor quality, cracking after non-penetrating hits. (Credit: Jeeps_Guns_Tanks)
              真相:豹子,哪怕是后期型号,也是机械问题不断,比如150km抛锚。The_Chieftain对此有描述
              http://worldoftanks.com/en/news/21/chieftains-hatch-french-panthers/
              另外,豹子装甲的质量实在堪忧,哪怕没有击穿,也会崩裂。


              IP属地:广东16楼2013-09-09 10:11
              收起回复
                Myth: A SuperPershing knocked out a King Tiger at Dassau.
                流言:超潘在Dassau干掉过虎王诶~~~
                Fact: Only if it had a teleporter of some kind.
                真相:如果有传送门的话还真有可能。http://ftr.wot-news.com/2013/08/04/the-not-so-duel-at-dessau/


                IP属地:广东17楼2013-09-09 10:11
                收起回复
                  2025-08-06 06:49:02
                  广告
                  不感兴趣
                  开通SVIP免广告
                  好像没有被吞贴,全篇结束


                  IP属地:广东24楼2013-09-09 10:15
                  收起回复


                    IP属地:广东25楼2013-09-09 10:42
                    回复


                      IP属地:广东26楼2013-09-09 10:45
                      收起回复
                        谢谢你的辛苦


                        来自Android客户端27楼2013-09-09 11:18
                        收起回复
                          很好很强大,顶上去让更多人看到,顺带挽尊


                          IP属地:陕西28楼2013-09-09 11:34
                          收起回复
                            真相太多。。。
                            这是钓鱼还是打脸?


                            IP属地:四川29楼2013-09-09 11:37
                            收起回复
                              2025-08-06 06:43:02
                              广告
                              不感兴趣
                              开通SVIP免广告
                              地摊文学家。


                              IP属地:河北来自手机贴吧30楼2013-09-09 11:40
                              收起回复