冷兵器吧 关注:567,008贴子:4,222,249
  • 24回复贴,共1

【转自弓会】清弓箭速测试

只看楼主收藏回复

老外的测试,原文
Today was a good day! My heavy
82# Manchu bow proved its worth with a stunning 190 fps with an arrow of around
80 grams. A yew longbow of 119# got an impressive 170 fps from the same arrow
but the test clearly showed the Manchu bow's potential. Both were shot by the
same archer, Fairbow Nederland using the three finger draw. More detailed
results will follow, and of course we will do lots more testing in the coming
period. Thanks Magén!
Will be
continued...
we wanted to compare
speed/arrow/bow, so we were shooting same arrow different bows sort of tests. it
was made very very clear drawweight is not as relevant as many think. some
designs just like heavier arrows.
the english longbow and Manchu
bow are very alike. although in this case it seems the longbow is easier to pull
and shoot (at least for me) and the Manchu bow wins in kinetc energy up to 100
gram arrows, then the longbow takes over in kinetic energy. and in this case it
should as that was 119@32 and the manchu was just approx.
80@32.
the korean design, 80@28 did
noyt like heavy arrows at all and performed shit with heavy arrows. BUT
lightwweight arrows it blasted those out of the little bow. easily doing over
230
fps
测试弓,
清弓82磅,射80克箭190fps
紫杉长弓119磅,射80克箭170fps
比对Adam土耳其弓测试结果
土弓75.5磅,射69克箭,155fps,射100克箭,130fps
土弓92磅,射69克箭,168.3fps,射100克箭,141.5fps
比对之下清弓效率好相十分优异,但这只是射重箭的结果,如果射20以下的箭,土弓箭速可轻易飙破三百,清弓可能还是两百初,而且等同空放,手震会震到心坎里
清弓其实也就是大反曲的"长"弓,大反曲增加蓄能,弓臂长可增加拉距也增加了蓄能,一种近距离的掷矛器,原本的设计就不是给正常人拉的,谁说清弓手感好?
那是轻磅的清弓,重磅弓开弓到满弓是从头重到尾,像这把80磅的,拉距17英吋60磅,老外说100磅英长还好拉一点
最后,不要把武器神话,以上都是"传统弓"测试,同磅数要比箭速比蓄能,现代复合弓永远是最强的

下面这把

这弓其实有175到178公分,多少我忘了,这老外快头大,弓看起来有点小

英长120磅,够猛

测速器



1楼2013-01-16 12:03回复
    2楼2013-01-16 12:04
    回复
      2026-01-05 18:18:58
      广告
      不感兴趣
      开通SVIP免广告
      这弓很短•••••


      3楼2013-01-16 12:10
      回复


        放两张貌似是宇宙国的古董弓


        4楼2013-01-16 12:13
        收起回复
          挽尊。


          IP属地:陕西来自Android客户端5楼2013-01-16 12:38
          回复
            国内有土耳其弓卖么


            IP属地:安徽来自Android客户端6楼2013-01-16 13:44
            回复
              挽尊


              IP属地:安徽来自Android客户端7楼2013-01-16 15:27
              回复
                受教。这文让我明白了古弓的效率也很高。毕竟是以前为杀人制作的武器。
                第二个看来箭重增加到一定量的时候,速度下降的没想象中的严重。我怀疑这玩意的效率说不到超过了同磅数的反曲弩


                IP属地:广东来自iPhone客户端8楼2013-01-16 15:37
                回复
                  2026-01-05 18:12:58
                  广告
                  不感兴趣
                  开通SVIP免广告
                  震惊,清弓的每磅产生焦耳数等同于现代反复合弓?而且动能相差不大。虽然箭重不一样,但那可是现代复合弓啊,而且拉锯要三十英寸。远远大于清弓的17。5


                  IP属地:广东来自iPhone客户端9楼2013-01-16 15:47
                  回复


                    10楼2013-01-16 22:25
                    回复
                      满洲弓不是给正常人拉的?是不是只有高速弓才是正常人用的呢?低速弓就一文不值? 一群人拿满洲弓射轻箭和高速弓比效率,然后说满洲弓效率低,岂不可笑?低速弓有低速弓的玩法。满洲弓所能达到的动能是其他弓形望尘莫及的,
                      满洲弓由于有弦垫,手感类似滑轮弓,刚开始拉的时候会更费力,但拉到后面会变轻,可以开更大拉锯,老外玩惯了小拉锯的长弓,觉得手感差很正常。


                      IP属地:北京11楼2013-01-16 22:47
                      收起回复
                        同一个人 清弓配重箭可以输出最大的动能 同样的蓄能 突厥系弓配轻箭可以达到最高的箭速


                        IP属地:四川来自手机贴吧12楼2013-01-16 23:26
                        回复
                          清弓拉满拉力会变轻?扯淡
                          这是我拿一把长稍清弓实测的拉力数据曲线,最后一点是拉距86cm下38磅


                          13楼2013-01-17 01:19
                          收起回复
                            个人推测这种长弓重箭的类型是为应对越来越强的个人防护而产生的,不过等这个形制完善稳定也差不多到玩儿火器的时代了...


                            14楼2013-01-17 15:37
                            收起回复